H-cobordisms, Manifolds and Poincare

 The h-cobordism theorem is essentially the following result: Let $M$ be a simply connected $N-$cobordism (with $N\geq 6$) between $V_{0}^{N-1}$ and $V_{1}^{N-1}$. Then, $M\xrightarrow{\;\cong\;}V_{0}^{N-1}\times [0, 1]$. Then, if $M$ is a contractible manifold, one has $M\xrightarrow{\;\cong\;}\mathbb{D}^{N}$. We can prove this as follows: Let $\mathfrak{G}$ be an embedding of $\mathbb{D}^{N}$ into $M$ and identify the interior $\mathrm{Int}(\mathbb{D})$, for which $M-\mathfrak{G}\left(\mathrm{Int}(\mathbb{D}) \right)$ is a cobordism $\partial M\Longleftrightarrow \mathbb{S}^{N-1}$. If we piece these sections back, we would have $M$ from $\mathbb{D}^{N-1}$ and the cobordism $M-\mathfrak{G}\left(\mathrm{Int}\left(\mathbb{D} \right) \right)\equiv \mathcal{B}$. The following pushout diagram shows this decomposition:

Here, $\mathcal{B}$ is simply connected (due to homotopy cofiber sequence $\mathbb{S}^{N-1}\to \mathcal{B}\to M$), and therefore, one can has $\mathbb{S}^{N-1}\xrightarrow{\;H\cong\;}\mathcal{B}$, where $A\xrightarrow{\;H\cong\;}B$ denotes homotopic equivalence. Now, one can use the h-cobordism result from theorem to identify that $\mathcal{B}\xrightarrow{\;\cong\;} \mathbb{S}^{N-1}\times [0, 1]$. Gluing $\partial \mathbb{D}$ back, one sees that $M\xrightarrow{\;\cong\;}\mathbb{D}^{N-1}$, completing the proof. Then, we note the follows: Given a map $\mathfrak{G}$ between $\mathbb{S}^{N-1}$, one can identify that there exists a homeomorphism $\mathfrak{F}$ between $\mathbb{D}^{N}$:

Then, the Poincare conjecture can be rewritten into the follows: An $N-$manifold that is homotopy equivalent to the $\mathbb{S}^{N}$ is also homeomorphic to $\mathbb{S}^{N}$. As you can guess at this point, the proof of this is somewhat straightforward in terms of the decomposition of the primes $\mathbb{D}^{N}_{\pm }$ and $\mathbb{S}^{N-1}_{\pm }$ under the assumption of the h-cobordism theorem. The proof is as follows. The first diagram shows the decomposition of $M=\mathbb{D}_{0}^{N}\sqcup \mathcal{B}\sqcup \mathbb{D}_{1}^{N}$ by identifying the boundaries of the disks and $M-\mathfrak{G}\left(\mathrm{Int}\left(\mathbb{D}_{0}^{N}\sqcup \mathbb{D}_{1}^{N} \right) \right)\equiv \mathcal{B}$. Next, using the Alexandrov trick to induce $\mathfrak{F}$ on $\mathbb{D}^{N}$ from $\mathfrak{G}$ homeomorphism induced on $\mathbb{S}$, we would get the second diagram below:

From the second diagram where we used the Alexandrov trick, we see that there is a homeomorphism between $\mathbb{S}^{N}$ and $M$ by identifying the maps of the $N-$disks. However, in using the h-cobordism theorem, one has to be sure that the inclusion maps \textit{indeed} have the homotopy equivalence nature. This can be found as a lemma: 

Lemma: If $M$ is homotpic to $\mathbb{S}^{N}$ and $\mathcal{B}$ is a cobordism between $\mathbb{S}_{0}^{N-1}$ and $\mathbb{S}_{1}^{N-1}$ as obtained from the subtraction of the $N-$disk images $M-\mathfrak{G}\left(\mathrm{Int}\left(\mathbb{D}_{0}^{N}\sqcup \mathbb{D}_{1}^{N} \right) \right)$, then $\mathbb{S}_{0}^{N-1}\hookrightarrow \mathcal{B}$ is a homotopy equivalence.

Due to the above lemma, one can use the h-cobordism theorem to show that there is a homeomorphism between $\mathbb{S}^{N}$ and $M$, concluding our proof. This proof works (with several subtleties) in $N\geq 6$. This discussion is taken from my notes. However, the Ricci flow approach is much more interesting, since it has a lot to do with the finite-time existence of singularities. Based on the nature of prime decomposition, the works of Hamilton and others, and most importantly Perelman, showed that one can do surgery and continue Ricci flow. To illustrate this, consider the neckpinch characterized by the nature of a pullback being a shrinking cylinder soliton. To prove Poincare from Ricci flow, one has to show the finite time existence of the connected sum decomposition, which forms the basis of Perelman's work.

Bulk Physics, Algebras and All That: Part One

 A set of notes, titled Bulk Physics, Algebras and All That, which I have been writing from a couple of weeks has been almost completed. This set of notes is split into three parts -- part one, where bulk reconstruction and aspects of subregion duality are discussed; part two, where most of the focus is on QES and things like their relation to the information problem in AdS/CFT is presented; and part three, where some of the recent things I learnt about JT gravity and SYK model are discussed. Part three still needs some work, but as of now part one has been completed. There are some omissions and refinements to take into account in future revisions, due to which for now, here is part one.

Bulk Physics, Algebras and All That -- Part One: Bulk Reconstruction and Subregions

Review paper on de Sitter and Holography

A review paper on de Sitter and holography that I have been collaborating on with Aayush Verma has been completed. While this is a preliminary version and we may not arXiv it immediately (perhaps after some more refinements), the present state of the paper justifies to an extent the title. It is based on discussions on the general aspects of de Sitter, holographic entanglement entropy from usual dS/CFT and bit threads, the recent works by Suvrat et al on the Hilbert space of de Sitter quantum gravity, the work on algebra of observables in de Sitter space by Chandrasekharan, Longo, Pennington and Witten, some brief aspects of Cauchy slice holography by Wall et al, and finally a mention of bulk reconstruction in the sense of dS/CFT. In upcoming revisions, we will elaborate on some aspects and include further works, such as cosmic ER=EPR by Cotler and Strominger, dS/dS, and Balasubramaniam et al's works on de Sitter space.

U-boats

The history of naval warfare is perhaps one of the most intriguing things, and I am not hesitant to admit that I am obsessed with reading about these things. And one cannot talk about naval warfare and not talk about U-boats (or U-boots as they were called in the Kriegsmarine). So this post is to share a bit on the effectiveness of U-boats.

Keep in mind that after WW1 Germany was forced to minimize military forces under the Treaty of Versailles. And then Hitler came along, and here Germany saw a massive expansion in the armed forces, particularly interestingly, the Luftwaffe and the Kriegsmarine. The latter developed powerful dreadnoughts like the Bismarck (lost tied to Operation Rheinubung, which also involved Prinz Eugen), Tripitz, Lutzow, and many others. But the particularly interesting class of developments were in the family of U-boats, which had two essential armaments -- a deck gun, which I think was usually an 8.8 SK/C-35, and around 14 torpedos. To quote Winston Churchill is to best describe how effective these were in raiding shipping lanes in Wolfpack operations: ``the only thing that really frightened me during the [second world] war was the U-boats peril". Eventually, of course, the effectiveness declined because of anti-submarine warfare (ASW) like Hedgehog (which had bow-forward throwing mortars), Depth charges (these were usually the more effective ones, more below) and the Leigh light among others. One more thing that happened in this period was the cracking of the Enigma from U-boat wrecks, which was a major turning point in the war.

From a purely psychological perspective, there were a number of pressures on U-boat crews. More often than not, they would be subject to hours of constant depth charging, which was a technique that turned out to be quite effective. This was because the Depth charges, thrown to the stern-backward would not have to necessarily impact the U-boat, or even detonate anywhere close to it; it only sufficed to explode in a certain radius for the U-boat to have significant damage, usually damaging ballasts, steering, sonar or the entire U-boat altogether. And since U-boats had to recharge batteries, they would have to surface, which they usually did at night in the early war periods. However, after aerial spotting and bombings of U-boats became superior, this was pushed to the day time. Before the Allies developed an effective countermeasure to U-boats (which initially did not work so well), U-boat campaigns were very successful. They referred to the time period around July, 1940 as the First Happy Time, or Die Gluckliche Zeit. There is a Second Happy Time as well, however I won't discuss this.

For that matter, U-boats in WW1 were also recognized as a threat -- however, they did not operate at the scale seen in WW2. The sinking of Lusitania and the Arabic significantly increased pressure on the American-German relations, and at that point the predictability of a move from Britain was not unseen. In the August of 1915, the Baralong incidents took place, which in a single line can be summarized by ``... [unofficially] ... take no prisoners from U-boats". While this was seen as a British war crime, many say that the provocation of the U-boats was not minor, since attacking Lusitania was in itself a crime, although the German claim was that this was justified since Lusitania could also be classified as an auxiliary cruiser. Joining the dots, it should be clear that there are many aspects of historic value involved when discussing just the one topic of U-boats. Of course, there are many other historically significant cases, like Battle of Jutland, Operation Rheinubung, and many others. In fact, the Battle of Jutland is one of three actions in a major war that involved battleships, after Battle of Yellow Sea and most notably, the Battle of Tsushima, which is famous for Admiral Togo's strategic ``U-turn", which crossed-the-T of Admiral Rozhestvensky's fleet. Tsushima is also famous for Admiral Togo's famous quote, ``Weather today fine, but high waves". However, more on these later. 

Botez Gambit! And two new papers

 I have been somewhat obsessed with chess recently, after successfully winning my tenth game day before yesterday. However, often unsuccessfully, I have found myself making the mistake of trying the Botez Gambit. However, I was successful in ensuring that every time my Queen was lost, the opponent's psychology would be at stake. Partly since the opponent may overestimate the value of the Queen in the particular scenario we would be in, due to which I would be able to either also take off the board the opponent's Queen, or ruin the endgame for the opponent altogether. I will add to this post some of my musings and a particularly interesting experience (so far) to this post once I get time. Also, on today's arXiv, we have the following two nice papers:

Thermal Bekenstein-Hawking entropy from the worldsheet

What if Quantum Gravity is "just'' Quantum Information Theory?

Holographic Entanglement Entropy without Holography

 Today, in the morning, I was learning how to do the Botez Gambit without making it a fail, when (after failing to make good of it in the last 30 seconds) I opened arXiv and saw a paper by Marolf and collaborators. The paper has to do with the notion of Ryu-Takayanagi and Hubeny-Rangamani-Takayanagi without AdS/CFT. While this particular title seems to not be very new (since bit threads are independent of holography up to a certain extent), the paper in itself is an amazing read, and unless Engelhardt and Liu's work on Algebraic ER=EPR comes out this month (which I hope it does), this would be the read of the month. Pasterski and collaborators also had a paper, but I am not into celestial holography, so I cannot say anything about it. 

Algebras and Hilbert spaces from gravitational path integrals: Understanding Ryu-Takayanagi/HRT as entropy without invoking holography

Extremal surfaces in de Sitter

 Today, a paper by K. Narayan came up on arXiv. However, I had the privilege of seeing the draft from two days earlier, and here is a quick glimpse on why these extremal surfaces are important. From AdS/CFT, we know that extremal surfaces are the things that make up the entanglement wedge, where we do all sorts of nice things like entanglement wedge reconstruction, make sense of subregion-subalgebra duality (at least motivationally) and calculate entanglement entropy, etc. One interesting thing is that of phase transitions, where if you vary the area of a two-component boundary subregion, the corresponding entanglement wedges eventually coincide, and you will be able to reconstruct a bulk operator deeper than before. But, such kinds of things only exist because these extremal surfaces have that interpretation. In dS/CFT, this becomes a very subtle question: if one does construct entanglement entropy (which we nicely can), what subreion duality could we possibly construct? Clearly this has to be Lorentzian, i.e. into the bulk from $\mathcal{I}^{+}$ to $\mathcal{I}^{-}$ (without ``turning points" going to the same boundary), due to which we have to make sense of extremal surfaces going timelike. This paper has a very nice description of the extremal surfaces, and I have some thoughts on a possible reconstruction scheme in this scenario. However, it must be noted that, while subregion duality has been previously highlighted in AdS/CFT with the backing of type III$_{1}$ von Neumann algebras associated to the bulk and boundary subregions, I am not sure about the nature of algebras in this case. So, things like JLMS and pure bulk reconstruction schemes do not exist as of yet. However, this is an interesting field, and I think the next big thing will be in dS/CFT.

Physicists Joking Around

 A little strange for a post, but I found this interesting video on YouTube that I found nice. I found this after searching for ``physicist breaks down", which is a gag video from The Big Bang Theory show, where Sheldon drinks alcohol and jokes around. I have linked both the videos, in case you want to have some time off from work.

Theoretical Physicists having fun & cracking jokes

Physicist Melts Down (TBBT)

Paper by Flam, Leutheusser and Satischandran

 A new paper had appeared yesterday by Flam, Leutheusser and Satischandran, called Generalized Black hole entropy is von Neumann Entropy. I have to read this, although I am having to go through Liu and Leutheusser's three previous works for my works.

Generalized Black Hole Entropy is von Neumann Entropy

Papers for beginners in AdS/CFT!

 For people who are interested in what I am doing (in AdS, while dS has some other works as well), here are some papers that are worth referring to, since most of my works are based around these results. Mainly, the following are people whose works are extensively referred to: Raphael Bousso, Netta Engelhardt, Andy Strominger, Aron Wall, Tadashi Takayanagi, Veronika Hubeny, Mukund Rangamani, Shinsei Ryu, Geoff Pennington, Ahmed Almheiri, Juan Maldacena, Ed Witten, Thomas Faulkner, Aitor Lewkowycz, and Horacio Casini. Of course, there are many others, but in AdS/CFT, these are some of the key ones. Keep in mind that these are not in any chronology; I am working on a review, in which perhaps I will detail on this.


    And there are some other works too, but for now I think these are nice. 

    Modular flows, operators and AdS/CFT

    See Weisbrock's paper on half-sided modular inclusions. This finds a very striking application in Ceyhan and Faulkner's paper on finding QNEC from ANEC, and in Bousso, Rath, Chandrasekharan and Mogghadam's work on the gravitational dual to the Connes cocycle flow. In AdS/CFT, this is very successful, and I think there are some other papers that use modular theory, and I will add some more papers soon.

    Pseudo-Hermitian Quantum Mechanics

    Lately, I have been caught up with some works requiring me to extensively think about the possibilities of un-Hermitian quantum mechanics. One of these was that the existence of higher spin theories as dS/CFT, initiated by Anninos and collaborators. While I am really naive about this, I think there could be motivations to pseudo-Hermitian quantum mechanics particularly in de Sitter, and with important implications to calculating entanglement entropy. While on this topic, Jacob Barnett arXived his thesis, entitled Locality and Exceptional Points in Pseudo-Hermitian Physics a while back. The appendix of this thesis discusses many elementary aspects of the mathematics involved in the thesis. 

    And on the topic of papers in dS, there is a nice paper today that I wish to read eventually: Unitary-Preserving Holography in dS$_d$ [2309.02122]. 

    Complexity paper: Timelike separated QES

     Netta Engelhardt, Geoff Pennington and Arvin Shahbazi-Mogghadam had a paper on arXiv two days ago (the most recent posting*) on quantum extremal surfaces and Python's lunch. Interestingly, it also describes a kind of quantum extremal surface that resembles a de Sitter bifurcation surface.

    *Friday, 1st September, most recent since arXiv papers are not announced on weekends.

    Twice Upon a Time: Timelike-Separated Quantum Extremal Surfaces [2308.16226]

    Good Will Hunting

     Just two clips from Good Will Hunting (1997). This happens to be my comfort movie, which I would recommend to anyone wanting to see a movie feel like a nice hug. Matt Damon and Robin Williams definitely made this movie one of (if not) the most perfect movie. It is with reason that I ranked this first on my movies page. 

    • Perfect for Each Other: Sean (Robin Williams) telling Will (Matt Damon) about wife, and what made their relationship what it was -- the little things. One of the most heartfelt scenes I have seen in a movie. The camera shaking when Sean jokes about his wife, the suiting silence -- there are many things I can say just about this one scene.
    • It's Not Your Fault: Sean telling Will that his father causing his traumatic childhood is not something he has to reflect himself with. Again, one of the most heartfelt clips in a movie ever, particularly the almost child-like way Will holds Sean, who broke the emotional baggage that Will built up all his life.
    • Gotta Go See About a Girl: Sean talking about how he met his wife, missing the game, to which Will is perplexed. 

    Strings, strings and strings

     Today, on Twitter I came across a post by Thomas Van Riet [see here], that seeing Strings 2023, the name of the conference should be ``the conference previously known as Strings". This is true -- in fact, so much so that Aron Wall at the beginning of his talk said something along the lines of ``... I am going to do something unusual, and actually talk about string theory ...". Of course -- string talks were present quite nicely; for instance, Remmen gave a talk on his work with Cheung on bespoke dual resonance [2308.03833], Wall on off shell strings and black hole entropy, Sen on logarithmic corrections to supersymmetric black holes and Eberhardt for instance. That said, there were a number of talks that weren't exactly strings -- for instance, Suvrat's talk on the Hilbert space of de Sitter quantum gravity, Engelhardt on an algebraic ER=EPR with Hong Liu (something I am excited to read on, since I had some speculation on similar lines), and Strominger on cosmic ER=EPR in dS/CFT with Cotler. For that matter, a stringy context of de Sitter is something I (and presumably some other people) are wary of. The most ``trustworthy" paper I have read on de Sitter compactifications in string theory is the one by Van Riet, Bena and Grana [2303.17680]. However, I think the star of the show (pardon me for this statement; I found many other talks great as well, but... Well..) was Witten's talk on a background independent formalism for quantum gravity, based on the paper [2308.03663]. 

    But, unsurprisingly (since it is Twitter), some people pointed out some opposition to string theory. Well.. I suppose this is where I say that politics arises with trying to compete with string theory. Between Republicans and Democrats, I may be able to choose at some point given some understanding. But with string theory, I doubt anyone will ever say ``oh! Loops look better now!". Or indeed any other theory. Anyone saying ``that theory is wrong, this is better" are essentially trying to gamble with this false politics.

    P.S. Twitter is messed up. Millions of years of evolution and this is what it boils down to.